• Michael Levy
  • Barton Weitz
  • Dhruv Grewal
  • Digital
  • Videos
  • Newsletters
  • Syllabi

Retailing Management

~ 11th Edition

Retailing Management

Category Archives: Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

In the Novel Popcorn Bucket Market, Movie Theaters Confront an Age-Old Challenge: Buying Just the Right Amount

30 Wednesday Sep 2026

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

istockphoto / Cavan Images

Blockbuster movies represent cultural events. People flock to be among the first to catch the latest blockbuster, from Marvel and Star Wars films to 2023’s massively successful Barbie movie to 2026’s 70-millimeter extravaganza The Odyssey. So imagine: You’re a movie theater operator, selling a thrilling experience to a vast audience of willing consumers. They’re already in your retail location, and they are accustomed to spending money to enhance their experience with snacks and drinks. What else could you do to earn more of their entertainment budget?

Behold, the collectible popcorn bucket.

Rather than sell popped kernels in conventional paper bags, movie theaters have introduced “collectible concession vessels” that hold moviegoers’ favorite snack in themed, plastic buckets that the fans can take home with them after the credits roll. The first of these collectibles was released in conjunction with the 2019 Star Wars installment, The Rise of the Skywalker. Disney licensed the likeness of the droid R2-D2 to a company called Golden Link, which created a 17-inch version to hold popcorn. It sold well, signaling massive consumer demand. In response, the market expanded, with prices to match. Today, some of the special, limited-edition receptacles retail for up to $70, and resale markets among collectors exhibit even higher prices.

In an attempt to benefit from these opportunities, many studios have entered into partnerships with the three main bucket suppliers currently in existence: Golden Link (which mainly works with Disney), Snap, and Zinc. When these firms win a contract to provide the collectibles for a particular movie, they refer to it with a new verb: They “bucket” the film. The resulting bucketing contracts have proved remarkably popular and lucrative. According to AMC Theaters, buckets associated with the various movies it screens will earn $100 million in revenue in 2026, which is approximately twice the amount it earned in 2023.

A brand new revenue stream, with benefits for multiple members of the supply chain (i.e., bucket suppliers, film studios, and theater chains), seems like a fairy tale. But creating a new retail market also inherently involves challenges, as became abundantly clear in relation to the popcorn buckets for The Odyssey. Snap produced two different versions: a recreation of the 70-millimeter IMAX camera that Christopher Nolan used to shoot the epic and a 22-inch-high Trojan horse, sold for $50 and $70, respectively. Worried that people would not really be interested in the technical details surrounding the camera used for filming the movie, IMAX ordered only 2,500 of this version to stock its U.S. theaters.

It sold out within just 90 minutes. The online orders came in even before the film opened. The theater company then scrambled to find more, requesting the products that had been slated to ship to China (where the movie opened later than in the United States). That shipment of 2,500 more camera buckets sold out in 7 minutes. In the meantime, Snap was busy manufacturing more of the buckets, such that IMAX estimates it has sold 30,000 of the collectibles.

It was fortunate to be able to find an alternative source, to make up for its insufficient estimates of actual demand. On the basis of its experience, other studios and theaters might plan to purchase more. For example, noting the “unbelievable” demand for the buckets that Cinemark Theaters commissioned to commemorate the release of The Devil Wears Prada 2, one executive noted, “If I could do that one over again, I don’t even know if there’s a max I would buy.”

But predicting uncertain market demand, and then ordering an appropriate inventory level in this novel market, remains incredibly difficult, and ordering too much carries its own risks. Good predictive models are not yet available. For example, most analysts have proposed that demand for the collectibles comes mainly from younger, Gen Z consumers. But movies targeting this demographic have been responsible for some notable market failures. The Supergirl movie did not do well in theaters, and neither did its themed bucket, featuring the main character’s canine sidekick. Masters of the Universe also performed pretty poorly in terms of ticket sales, but its bucket outcomes varied: A version depicting Castle Grayskull (designed with a candy compartment and a detachable cup) sold massively, whereas the one made to look like Skeletor’s throne barely moved off theater shelves. Young viewers were the target markets for these films, whereas the popularity of the red, handbag-shaped buckets evoking The Devil Wears Prada sequel actually involved purchases by older women who had enjoyed the first movie when it launched, two decades ago.

The implications of poor buying decisions are critical. If they order too many, theaters are stuck with bulky, excessive inventory that they cannot easily sell, discount, or repurpose. Unlike conventional popcorn bags and paper buckets, the themed containers have a limited time appeal. Once the relevant movie leaves the theater, there’s virtually no more demand for leftover, unpopular vessels.

This challenge also appears likely to become even more pressing, as the bucket suppliers come up with new and more extreme versions. For example, marking a theater rerelease of a Harry Potter movie, filmgoers will encounter a four-foot replica of Harry’s broom, the bottom of which will hold 135 ounces of popcorn. Storing such large containers, in a way that still ensures they are food-safe, represents an ongoing challenge.

Other creative designs create an opposite problem, because in prioritizing the cleverness of the visual design, the resulting containers cannot hold enough popcorn to satisfy hungry filmgoers. Then theaters confront a different problem (or perhaps an opportunity) associated with forcing viewers to leave the film to come get refills of their snacks (and maybe buy something else while they’re there).

All these questions remain to be resolved. Like a good thriller, the twists and turns that have marked the storyline of this new market are holding the interest of a lot of audiences.

Discussion Questions

  1. How should the sellers in this supply chain develop metrics to predict demand for collectible popcorn buckets for different movie releases? What are some of the factors they should take into consideration?
  2. Who should be responsible for dealing with unsold collectible buckets: the supplier, the film studio, or the theater chain? How might these actors establish a fair method among themselves?

Sources: Nicole Sperling, “Salty, Buttery, Astonishingly Lucrative: The $100 Million Market of Popcorn Buckets,” The New York Times, July 23, 2026; Matt Minton, “Popcorn Bucket Craze Pops Off with Skyrocketing Scalper Prices, Director Approvals and Imax’s First-Ever Movie Merch,” Variety, August 3, 2026.

Gallery

Kroger Launches Hundreds of Products, Designed to Reflect Consumer Trends

03 Monday Nov 2025

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 12: Managing the Merchandise Planning Process, Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tariffs are up, calories are out, and protein is key—if social media are to be believed. Followers might be excused …

Continue reading →

Gallery

Coming Apart at the Seams: Christian Dior Faces Reputational Damage

07 Monday Oct 2024

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise, Chapter 14: Retail Pricing

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

bags, brand, Quality, reputation

This gallery contains 1 photo.

When Jennifer Lawrence accepted her Academy Award for Best Actress in 2013, she tripped and fell on her way up …

Continue reading →

Gallery

The Latest Developments in Krispy Kreme’s Efforts to Get You Your Daily Glazed

15 Monday Apr 2024

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 04: Multichannel and Omnichannel Retailing, Chapter 08: Retail Locations, Chapter 09: Retail Site Location, Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Donuts, Krispy Kreme, McDonald's

This gallery contains 1 photo.

As we discussed previously in these abstracts, McDonald’s and Krispy Kreme entered into a novel partnership in late 2022, making …

Continue reading →

Gallery

Playing the Global Field to Find a Stable Source of Toys

11 Monday Mar 2024

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

China, merchandise, Production, Supply Chain, Toys

This gallery contains 1 photo.

Multiple global trends drive manufacturers’ choices about where they want to locate their plants. In recent years, the challenges of …

Continue reading →

Gallery

Retailing Tidbit: Target and Marks & Spencer are Making Luxury Goods Affordable

25 Wednesday Jan 2023

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 06: Retail Market Strategy, Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Budget, Luxury, Marks & Spencer, Target

As we have recounted previously in these abstracts, Target was something of a game-changer when it came to introducing luxury, …

Continue reading →

Gallery

Want FAO Schwarz Toys? Take a Trip to Target!

02 Wednesday Nov 2022

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 12: Managing the Merchandise Planning Process, Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

FAO Schwarz, Target, Toys

This announcement could be a game changer, literally and figuratively: Target just announced an exclusive, multi-year agreement with legendary toy …

Continue reading →

Gallery

Bullwhip Effects and Just-in-Case Inventory Management in COVID-Era Supply Chains

18 Monday Jul 2022

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 10: Information Systems and Supply Chain Management, Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Buying Merchandise, overstocking, Supply Chain Management

When consumers struggled to find access to goods that they needed and wanted during the COVID-19 pandemic (e.g., toilet paper, …

Continue reading →

Gallery

Birkenstock Makes Comfortable Shoes, Uncomfortable Business Demands

27 Monday Jun 2022

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Birkenstock, Buying Merchandise

Birkenstock is trying to be your favorite summer sandal, even if it has to shove all the other sandal-makers out …

Continue reading →

Gallery

Beautiful, Sustainable, and Conscious: Setting New Standards for Cosmetics at Ulta

09 Wednesday Sep 2020

Posted by Retailing Management in Chapter 12: Managing the Merchandise Planning Process, Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise

≈ Leave a comment

Tags

Buying Merchandise, Conscious Beauty, cosmetics, Managing Merchandise Planning, Ulta

The old saying that beauty is only skin deep reflects the ethical recognition that appearances are superficial and less important …

Continue reading →

← Older posts

Blog Stats

  • 147,248 hits

Articles by Chapter

  • Chapter 01: Introduction to the World of Retailing (20)
  • Chapter 02: Types of Retailers (85)
  • Chapter 03: Digital Retailing (25)
  • Chapter 04: Multichannel and Omnichannel Retailing (100)
  • Chapter 05: Customer Buying Behavior (90)
  • Chapter 06: Retail Market Strategy (196)
  • Chapter 07: Financial Strategy (52)
  • Chapter 08: Retail Locations (48)
  • Chapter 09: Retail Site Location (25)
  • Chapter 10: Information Systems and Supply Chain Management (111)
  • Chapter 11: Customer Relationship Management (57)
  • Chapter 12: Managing the Merchandise Planning Process (61)
  • Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise (69)
  • Chapter 14: Retail Pricing (78)
  • Chapter 15: Retail Communication Mix (64)
  • Chapter 16: Human Resources and Managing the Store (76)
  • Chapter 17: Store Layout, Design, and Visual Merchandising (62)
  • Chapter 18: Customer Service (77)
  • Retail Tidbits (130)
  • Uncategorized (6)

Tags

AI Amazon Artificial Intelligence Buying Merchandise China Customer Buying Behavior Customer Relationship Management Customer service CVS Delivery Ethics Fashion financial strategy Global Grocery Human Resource Management Ikea Information Systems Introduction to Retailing Kroger Luxury Macy's Malls Managing Merchandise Planning Managing the Store McDonald's Millennials Mobile Apps Multichannel Retailing Online retailing Pricing Retail Communication Mix Retail Locations Retail Market Strategy Retail Pricing Retail Tidbit Store Design Store Layout Supply Chain Management Target Technology Types of Retailers visual merchandising Walmart Whole Foods

RSS Feed

  • RSS - Posts

Articles by Chapter

  • Chapter 01: Introduction to the World of Retailing (20)
  • Chapter 02: Types of Retailers (85)
  • Chapter 03: Digital Retailing (25)
  • Chapter 04: Multichannel and Omnichannel Retailing (100)
  • Chapter 05: Customer Buying Behavior (90)
  • Chapter 06: Retail Market Strategy (196)
  • Chapter 07: Financial Strategy (52)
  • Chapter 08: Retail Locations (48)
  • Chapter 09: Retail Site Location (25)
  • Chapter 10: Information Systems and Supply Chain Management (111)
  • Chapter 11: Customer Relationship Management (57)
  • Chapter 12: Managing the Merchandise Planning Process (61)
  • Chapter 13: Buying Merchandise (69)
  • Chapter 14: Retail Pricing (78)
  • Chapter 15: Retail Communication Mix (64)
  • Chapter 16: Human Resources and Managing the Store (76)
  • Chapter 17: Store Layout, Design, and Visual Merchandising (62)
  • Chapter 18: Customer Service (77)
  • Retail Tidbits (130)
  • Uncategorized (6)

Tags

AI Amazon Artificial Intelligence Buying Merchandise China Customer Buying Behavior Customer Relationship Management Customer service CVS Delivery Ethics Fashion financial strategy Global Grocery Human Resource Management Ikea Information Systems Introduction to Retailing Kroger Luxury Macy's Malls Managing Merchandise Planning Managing the Store McDonald's Millennials Mobile Apps Multichannel Retailing Online retailing Pricing Retail Communication Mix Retail Locations Retail Market Strategy Retail Pricing Retail Tidbit Store Design Store Layout Supply Chain Management Target Technology Types of Retailers visual merchandising Walmart Whole Foods

Proudly powered by WordPress Theme: Chateau by Ignacio Ricci.

 

Loading Comments...
 

You must be logged in to post a comment.